Friday, July 25, 2008

Book Review: David Aikman's 'Delusion of Disbelief'

from Arizona Atheist -
Aikman, like every other theist, tries to place the "four horsemen" (Dawkins, Hitchens, Dennett, and Harris) in a bad light, seemingly trying to discredit them before he even begins to address their arguments. If theists don't attack the four authors directly they try the old atheism is responsible for communism and nazism bit (Aikman does exactly that in chapter 5). As I've said before, I think this new strategy is an attempt to discredit the logical philosophy of materialism by equating it with evil acts, which is just a logical fallacy in itself (the 'poisoning of the well' fallacy).

In my opinion, this new approach is due, at least in part, to the fact that theists have had their arguments critiqued and destroyed and they have been unable to prove their case. Because of this, they've decided to attack the materialistic philosophy directly, but again they have failed.

More HERE.

1 comment:

Arizona Atheist said...

Hi, thanks for posting a link to my review. I hope you enjoyed it.